CASTE
DISCRIMINATION DOES NOT EXIST IN BRITAIN
(18 June 2008)
A
report released by the Hindu Forum of Britain (HFB), 'Caste in the
UK' has found that Caste discrimination is not endemic in British
society. The report exposes MPs who have failed to declare in the
Members Register that they sit on the Board of lobbying organisations
on whose behalf they have run many campaigns in the House of Commons.
MPs whose links to Dalit and Christian organisations have not been
declared in Members Register even though they have camaigned on
their behalf in Parliament include Andy Reed, Rob Marris, Alistair
Burt and Jeremy Corbyn.
The
HFB Report also calls for a parliamentary enquiry into the activities
of these MPs, who have created a strong lobby in Parliament backed
by several Christian groups to highlight issues of caste discrimination
in India, particularly amongst the Dalit communities. Although MPs
do not have to declare unremunerated interests, it could be seen
as 'good practice' to declare formal links if they are campaigning
in Parliament on behalf of these organisations.
The
MPs named in the report have run the Parliamentary Dalit campaign
on behalf of organisations like Christian Solidarity Worldwide and
the Dalit Solidarity Network. Several of these MPs also have Research
Assistants funded by Christian Action Research and Education, a
Christian lobying group that has been described in some newspaper
reports as being 'right wing'.
Ramesh
Kallidai, secretary general of the Hindu Forum of Britain, said:
"There has been some criticism against the Hindu caste system
with regards to the treatment of Dalits in the Britain. However,
it is not right for the UK Government to take a position on the
rites, beliefs or practices of a particular religion. Social interactions
and personal choices are an expression of people's freedom, and
any barriers should be removed through education and awareness,
not through legislation."
Respondents
to the HFB survey say that they have not experienced caste discrimination
in the provision of education, employment or goods and services
in the UK. However, due to cultural practises and tradition, caste
can sometimes play a role in social interactions and personal choices
like marriages, conversations and friendships. Respondents have
suggested that the extent of the problem has been exaggerated and
requested that the Government should not interfere in personal choices
and matters of social interaction. Instead, community organisations
should be empowered to break any existing barriers to promote further
intra-community integration and cohesion.
Rickie
Sehgal of Transputec Computers who is Chair of the HFB Governance
Committee said, "We believe that this is an important issue
that needs to be brought to light. Why should MPs funded by Christian
organisations campaign for Dalit discrimination in the Hindu community?
Could it be because the evangelists in India keep playing the Dalit
card to increase the number of converts? Over 70% of the Christians
in India have been converted from the Dalit community under promise
of equality in the Christian faith. Our report however highlights
that even after conversion to Christianity, Dalits in India continue
to face discrimination in the Church by 'higher caste' Christians.
They are even buried separately in different parts of the cemetery
and often have segregated seating areas during Church services.
Recently some people were killed in a riot in South India between
higher-caste Vanniyar Christians and lower-caste Dalit Christians.
Promising equality on the basis of conversion and then denying them
that is misleading."
The
HFB report recommends that the Hindu leadership in the UK should
find ways of respecting traditions and challenging bias based on
family background or religious tradition within the community, as
well as supporting the creation of unity across castes, sects and
traditions through a structured programme of outreach and positive
interaction.
It
suggests that community organisations, like the HFB, should be empowered
by the Government to undertake education programmes in partnership
with Dalit organisations to address cultural and behavioural issues
faced through social interactions and personal choices.
MPS
WHO CAMPAIGN FOR DALIT & CHRISTIAN ORGANISATIONS
MPs
whose links to Dalit and Christian organisations have not been declared
in Members Register even though they have camaigned on their behalf
in Parliament include Andy Reed, Rob Marris, Alistair Burt and Jeremy
Corbyn.
Jeremy
Corbyn MP is the Chair of the Management Group of Dalit Solidarity
Network and is also a Trustee of the same organisation. Although
he has praised the work of the Dalit Solidarity Network several
times in the House of Commons, he has failed to declare his link
to this organisation in the 'Miscellaneous and unremunerated interests'
section of the Register of Members' Interests. Corbyn initiated
a Westminster Hall Debate on Dalits on 28 June 2007. He also asked
a written question on 5 June 2006 to the Secretary of State for
International Development on whether he would list the projects
in India that are supported by his Department that were specifically
aimed at Dalit peoples.
Rob
Marris MP is also a Trustee of Dalit Solidarity Network, and although
he has campaigned for Dalit rights several times on the floor of
the House of Commons, he too fails to declare his link to this organisation
in the 'Miscellaneous and unremunerated interests' section of the
Register of Members' Interests. In a statement to the House of Commons
on 8 May 2007, Rob Marris says: "There are thought to be 50,000
Dalits in the UK. We do not have numbers because we do not collect
figures." Despite admitting that he does not have numbers,
and is not collecting figures, Mr. Marris still gives a figure and
a number for the Dalit population - 'thought to be 50,000'!
Andy
Reed MP, who has a Research Assistant by Christian Action Research
and Education (CARE), has not declared in 'Miscellaneous and unremunerated
interests' section of the Members' Register that he sits on the
Board of Reference of Christian Solidarity Worldwide. He continues
to lobby extensively on behalf of CSW on the Dalit issue and has
visited other countries in trips sponsored by CSW. He has even led
a delegation to the Deputy Indian High Commissioner to discuss the
anti-conversion law in India.
Like
Andy Reed, Alistair Burt MP, who has a Research Assistant paid by
CARE, has also not declared in the 'Miscellaneous and unremunerated
interests' section of the Members' Register that he sits on the
Board of Reference of Christian Solidarity Worldwide. He continues
to lobby on Dalit issues, which is an issue that is high on CSW's
agenda.
ABOUT
THE HINDU FORUM OF BRITAIN
The
Hindu Forum of Britain is the representative umbrella body for British
Hindus with formal membership of over 300 Hindu organisations from
different regions and cultural backgrounds in Britain. The Hindu
Forum of Britain has conducted some of the largest community consultation
activities on behalf of the Hindu community to influence Government
policy and runs a number of projects for Hindu youth, women and
temples. Although the Hindu Forum is a national organisation, it
has a large regional presence through its membership from the largest
regional umbrella organisations, religious organisations, community
organisations and youth organisations.
For
more information visit ww.hfb.org.uk
|